Advanced Financial Planning and Value Based Management — A practical example

Key concepts

  • Advanced Financial Planning (AFP) – identify relevant value drivers, understand sensitivites and create what-if scenarios around key value drivers.
  • Value Based Management (VBM) as key concept to managing and executing strategy by identifying drivers that the company should focus on.
  • Measure and allocate cost of capital to optimize capital allocation
    in an organization.
  • When VBM and AFP are implemented, this can unleash tremendous value in the organizations by aligning strategy with operational execution and focusing the allocation of resources to where they can yield the highest returns.

Advanced Financial Planning 
and Value Based Management
— A practical example

Key concepts

  • Advanced Financial Planning (AFP) – identify relevant value drivers, understand sensitivites and create what-if scenarios around key value drivers.
  • Value Based Management (VBM) as key concept to managing and executing strategy by identifying drivers that the company should focus on.
  • Measure and allocate cost of capital to optimize capital allocation
    in an organization.
  • When VBM and AFP are implemented, this can unleash tremendous value in the organizations by aligning strategy with operational execution and focusing the allocation of resources to where they can yield the highest returns.

Value creation

Shareholders invest their funds in companies, putting their wealth at risk with the intention to receive a greater amount in return. If this is accomplished, in general, this can be considered value creation. 

The purpose of this White Paper is to highlight the methodologies used by companies to manage their value creation process based on VBM (Value Based Management) and to demonstrate how they align this with the Unified Performance Management (UPM) framework.

From an accounting perspective, profit can be defined as the amount of income exceeding costs. In many cases, this simple perspective is sufficient to define value creation.

Economic profit is defined as the amount by which cash inflow exceeds the costs associated with all factors. This not only includes expenses incurred in operating the business but also the cost of capital invested in the business.

As companies became more complex – mainly driven by globalization and technological developments, driving efficiency and growth – factors such as time differences, depreciation and amortization of assets, book versus tax accounting policies, and investments such as inventories and accounts receivable cause profits to become more difficult to measure. In addition, the continuous changes of international accounting standards (e.g. US-GAAP or IFRS) have led to more complexity with regard to the correct valuation of assets and liabilities. At the same time, the disparity between accounting profits and economic profits diverges more and more.

In order to create value, a company cannot only generate accounting profits, it must also generate economic profit to account for the cost of capital (usually referred to as WACC or Weighted Average Cost of Capital) and thus take into account the risk of investing in an asset. On the one hand, if a business does not produce sufficient return to generate Economic Profit, it will ultimately lose value. On the other, this also means that if a company only generates return  that is equal to the cost of capital, the value of the company will remain the same, i.e. the shareholder will simply have swapped one asset for another with the same value.

Time plays a very important role in assessing the value of a business. Normally, measuring profit over just one year does not capture whether value has been created or not, as investments in a business typically generate return over a longer period of time. This period, known as the economic life of an investment, is the relevant period for value measurement.

Assessing the value of a company (or a group), a business unit, division or legal entity is more of an art form than a science. But well-designed processes and models support value assessment, help companies to evaluate risk and allocate capital efficiently to drive value – through VBM and UPM.

 

Value creation

Shareholders invest their funds in companies, putting their wealth at risk with the intention to receive a greater amount in return. If this is accomplished, in general, this can be considered value creation. 

The purpose of this White Paper is to highlight the methodologies used by companies to manage their value creation process based on VBM (Value Based Management) and to demonstrate how they align this with the Unified Performance Management (UPM) framework.

From an accounting perspective, profit can be defined as the amount of income exceeding costs. In many cases, this simple perspective is sufficient to define value creation.

Economic profit is defined as the amount by which cash inflow exceeds the costs associated with all factors. This not only includes expenses incurred in operating the business but also the cost of capital invested in the business.

As companies became more complex – mainly driven by globalization and technological developments, driving efficiency and growth – factors such as time differences, depreciation and amortization of assets, book versus tax accounting policies, and investments such as inventories and accounts receivable cause profits to become more difficult to measure. In addition, the continuous changes of international accounting standards (e.g. US-GAAP or IFRS) have led to more complexity with regard to the correct valuation of assets and liabilities. At the same time, the disparity between accounting profits and economic profits diverges more and more.

In order to create value, a company cannot only generate accounting profits, it must also generate economic profit to account for the cost of capital (usually referred to as WACC or Weighted Average Cost of Capital) and thus take into account the risk of investing in an asset. On the one hand, if a business does not produce sufficient return to generate Economic Profit, it will ultimately lose value. On the other, this also means that if a company only generates return  that is equal to the cost of capital, the value of the company will remain the same, i.e. the shareholder will simply have swapped one asset for another with the same value.

Time plays a very important role in assessing the value of a business. Normally, measuring profit over just one year does not capture whether value has been created or not, as investments in a business typically generate return over a longer period of time. This period, known as the economic life of an investment, is the relevant period for value measurement.

Assessing the value of a company (or a group), a business unit, division or legal entity is more of an art form than a science. But well-designed processes and models support value assessment, help companies to evaluate risk and allocate capital efficiently to drive value – through VBM and UPM.

Advanced Financial Planning: Closing the loop

Advanced Financial Planning (AFP) is defined as a corporate financing model that looks at the profit & loss account, the balance sheet and cash flows – where the impact of all relevant business and value drivers is determined – from a profit, expense, asset, financing or capital perspective and this, in one coherent loop.

The basis for a functioning AFP model is the identification of the relevant value drivers of an organization and the ability to understand sensitivities of these as well as the competence to create what-if scenarios around the key value drivers.

AFP ultimately enables finance organizations to communicate the impact of plans to the respective stakeholders, from top management and executives to the board effectively.

VBM is based on a functioning AFP model, as it requires all aspects of value creation – profit and capital.

Advanced Financial Planning: 
Closing the loop

Advanced Financial Planning (AFP) is defined as a corporate financing model that looks at the profit & loss account, the balance sheet and cash flows – where the impact of all relevant business and value drivers is determined – from a profit, expense, asset, financing or capital perspective and this, in one coherent loop.

The basis for a functioning AFP model is the identification of the relevant value drivers of an organization and the ability to understand sensitivities of these as well as the competence to create what-if scenarios around the key value drivers.

AFP ultimately enables finance organizations to communicate the impact of plans to the respective stakeholders, from top management and executives to the board effectively.

VBM is based on a functioning AFP model, as it requires all aspects of value creation – profit and capital.

The theory of Value Based Management and how it fits with Unified Performance Management

Advanced Financial Planning (AFP) is defined as a corporate financing model that looks at the profit & loss account, the balance sheet and cash flows – where the impact of all relevant business and value drivers is determined – from a profit, expense, asset, financing or capital perspective and this, in one coherent loop.

The basis for a functioning AFP model is the identification of the relevant value drivers of an organization and the ability to understand sensitivities of these as well as the competence to create what-if scenarios around the key value drivers.

AFP ultimately enables finance organizations to communicate the impact of plans to the respective stakeholders, from top management and executives to the board effectively.

VBM is based on a functioning AFP model, as it requires all aspects of value creation – profit and capital.

The theory of Value Based Management 
and how it fits with Unified Performance 
Management

Advanced Financial Planning (AFP) is defined as a corporate financing model that looks at the profit & loss account, the balance sheet and cash flows – where the impact of all relevant business and value drivers is determined – from a profit, expense, asset, financing or capital perspective and this, in one coherent loop.

The basis for a functioning AFP model is the identification of the relevant value drivers of an organization and the ability to understand sensitivities of these as well as the competence to create what-if scenarios around the key value drivers.

AFP ultimately enables finance organizations to communicate the impact of plans to the respective stakeholders, from top management and executives to the board effectively.

VBM is based on a functioning AFP model, as it requires all aspects of value creation – profit and capital.

VBM as the key concept to managing and executing corporate strategy

The identification and management of value drivers draws the attention of management to activities that will have the greatest impact on value. Thus, management will be able to translate value creation into tangible and specific actions.

There are three categories of value drivers: growth drivers, efficiency drivers and financial drivers. By focusing on value drivers, management can prioritize the specific activities that will affect performance in each area (using KPIs to measure and manage performance and outcome).


To identify those value drivers that a company should focus on, the company has to address two key questions:

  • Which factors will have the most significant impact on future value creation for the business?
  • Which of these factors can be managed most effectively?

 

There are two simple ways to identify value drivers:

  • Value drivers have a significant value impact
  • Value drivers are controllable (e.g. commodity price inputs may be important to your business but since management does not influence them, they may not deserve significant management attention other than from a risk management perspective).

VBM as the key concept to managing 
and executing corporate strategy

The identification and management of value drivers draws the attention of management to activities that will have the greatest impact on value. Thus, management will be able to translate value creation into tangible and specific actions.

There are three categories of value drivers: growth drivers, efficiency drivers and financial drivers. By focusing on value drivers, management can prioritize the specific activities that will affect performance in each area (using KPIs to measure and manage performance and outcome).

To identify those value drivers that a company should focus on, the company has to address two key questions:

  • Which factors will have the most significant impact on future value creation for the business?
  • Which of these factors can be managed most effectively?

 

There are two simple ways to identify value drivers:

  • Value drivers have a significant value impact
  • Value drivers are controllable (e.g. commodity price inputs may be important to your business but since management does not influence them, they may not deserve significant management attention other than from a risk management perspective).

Value Driver Analysis

Value driver analysis is an important foundation for strategic planning: it helps management to identify and define critical strategic levers. If, for example, efficiency drivers are important to a company, management can direct strategic planning to focus on efficiency strategies and activities supporting it. In short, value drivers ensure that a strategy is grounded in the reality of operating performance.

Identifying value drivers is a three-step process

Step 1
— 
Develop a value driver “map”

To understand where your company’s value drivers lie, first, you need to break down the broad operating parameters of the business into progressively smaller components, until you reach the level where daily operations management decisions are made. Then, the specific factors influencing sales growth, operating profit (represented as NOPAT margin – net operating margin after tax), capital efficiency (capital turns), etc. are documented.

 

Step 2
— 
Test for driver sensibilities
 

The company must first define the basis level for each operating factor, after which it can test changes of each factor impact on the overall value of the business (based on net present value calculation methods such as the discounted cash flow method). This usually leads to valuable and interesting insights into the relevance of the specific operating factors and often also leads to a change of management priorities.

 

Step 3
— 
Test for controllability

 Each of the operating variables must then be examined to discover those that management can control and influence. 

A value driver analysis requires significant investments in terms of time and energy. It may also require information that is difficult to obtain and involves the development of an interrelationship model between variables within the business. This kind of complex modeling can be facilitated by the use of appropriate tools – such as functional databases like IBM Cognos TM1. Modern functional databases are designed to support this kind of modeling and sensitivity testing with multiple variables and large number of data sets. 

However, companies that have made this investment have discovered that this analysis helps to draw management’s attention to a manageable number of value drivers. Further, it provides a foundation to optimize the strategy around value driver performance and maximize value creation. 

 

Value Driver Analysis

Value driver analysis is an important foundation for strategic planning: it helps management to identify and define critical strategic levers. If, for example, efficiency drivers are important to a company, management can direct strategic planning to focus on efficiency strategies and activities supporting it. In short, value drivers ensure that a strategy is grounded in the reality of operating performance.

Identifying value drivers is a three-step process

Step 1
— 
Develop a value driver “map”

 

To understand where your company’s value drivers lie, first, you need to break down the broad operating parameters of the business into progressively smaller components, until you reach the level where daily operations management decisions are made. Then, the specific factors influencing sales growth, operating profit (represented as NOPAT margin – net operating margin after tax), capital efficiency (capital turns), etc. are documented.

Step 2
— 
Test for driver sensibilities

 

The company must first define the basis level for each operating factor, after which it can test changes of each factor impact on the overall value of the business (based on net present value calculation methods such as the discounted cash flow method). This usually leads to valuable and interesting insights into the relevance of the specific operating factors and often also leads to a change of management priorities.

Step 3
— 
Test for controllability

 

Each of the operating variables must then be examined to discover those that management can control and influence. 

A value driver analysis requires significant investments in terms of time and energy. It may also require information that is difficult to obtain and involves the development of an interrelationship model between variables within the business. This kind of complex modeling can be facilitated by the use of appropriate tools – such as functional databases like IBM Cognos TM1. Modern functional databases are designed to support this kind of modeling and sensitivity testing with multiple variables and large number of data sets. 

However, companies that have made this investment have discovered that this analysis helps to draw management’s attention to a manageable number of value drivers. Further, it provides a foundation to optimize the strategy around value driver performance and maximize value creation. 

What drives value: Focusing on what matters

The value driver matrix on the left illustrates a framework for the prioritization of value drivers.

The key task here is to identify those variables that reside in the red quadrant and to manage the resources directed at influencing variables in the orange quadrants.

Based on the insights gained during the value driver analysis, process management can easily assess where to allocate value drivers and communicate priorities effectively within the organization.

Measuring and allocating cost of capital
Valuing a business

What drives value:
Focusing on what matters

The value driver matrix on the left illustrates a framework for the prioritization of value drivers.

The key task here is to identify those variables that reside in the red quadrant and to manage the resources directed at influencing variables in the orange quadrants.

Based on the insights gained during the value driver analysis, process management can easily assess where to allocate value drivers and communicate priorities effectively within the organization.

Measuring and allocating cost of capital
Valuing a business

Keep on reading the Advanced Financial Planning White Paper by clicking here.

Get in touch today about FP&A and let’s explore its potential at your company together.

Get in touch today about FP&A and let’s explore its potential at your company together.

We’re proud to have helped these companies plan better.

Recent articles from the Apliqo FP&A blog

Recent articles from

the Apliqo FP&A blog

9 pillars of a well set up FP&A System, first time

When you’re first approaching any new FP&A system implementation, it can be very overwhelming.There is a lot to get right and the decisions you make early on will have an outsized impact on how the entire system works for you over the long term.Worst case a poor initial decision can have lasting consequences which you will need to live with. As a result, we always encourage new clients to take their time during the setup process and be as thorough as possible because it helps to avoid plenty of headaches down the road.

Read this article
9 pillars of a well set up FP&A system

How scenario stress-testing can help you weather the recession

After years of economic expansion, we’re finally seeing the tide turn again as we enter what looks like it will be an extended recession.When you consider the impact of the pandemic, widespread inflation, war in Ukraine, and supply chain issues across the board – this is not something that should surprise us.But if you haven’t been paying attention and considering the impact of a recession on your business, you might find yourself in that position.

Read this article
Scenario stress-testing to help you weather the recession

Understanding the impact of rising interest rates on your cash flow and your balance sheet

It’s safe to say that we’ve never before seen the scale of widespread cash injections that we saw during the COVID-19 pandemic.Governments across the world scrambled to print the money they needed to keep the economy afloat and provide the support that their citizens needed.The natural consequence of this has been rapid inflationary pressures which we wrote aboutlast week.

Read this article

How FP&A tools can help mitigate the impact of inflation on your business

If you tap into any current conversation about the global economy you’ll likely hear people talking about inflation.It’s the talk of the town – and for good reason.For decades, concerns about inflation were muted as we enjoyed one of the longest bull markets that we’ve seen in the modern era.But in 2022, it quickly became one of the most significant risks facing - as a result of the dramatic stimulus injected into local economies during the COVID-19 pandemic, continuing supply chain challenges, and a rapidly rising oil price.

Read this article
Mitigating the impact of growing inflation on your business

Notifications come to TM1 with Apliqo UX

Here at Apliqo, our products are continually evolving to cater to the needs of our users, and today we’re excited to announce a brand new feature that so many have been asking for.Within our Apliqo UX interface, we now havecontextual notificationswhich will help you to better collaborate with your colleagues and improve your own productivity and organization.

Read this article